Also, each fish generally has a different 'pattern' during the minigame, and higher quality fish generally have a more erratic pattern. if there are two fish with 50% chance, then it's a coin flip which one you'll end up getting. Again, this may vary depending on the sub-area if there was one fish with 100% chance, you'll catch that one. Once you've filled the progress bar, you have successfully caught whichever fish you were destined to catch. The minigame itself is relatively simple - just keep a yellow bar over a moving animation of a fish, and the green progress bar will fill up. Assuming you successfully reel-in on the bob, a minigame will start. If you make an attempt and fail to hit the bob, you'll take an energy hit *and* lose your bait. You can wait through these a couple times just to observe what it looks like, but note you'll take an energy hit every time you 'miss'. Now, to 'hook' the fish, you need to focus on the bobber and left-click/'E' (on PC) when it 'bobs' - generally takes ~8 seconds. If you were to then cast into that specific sub-area, you're on the right track. If at least one of them is there, you should see a change in chance below one (or more) question marks. only 7/16 fish are susceptible to the simple rod, only 3 of those are susceptible to the moth, and perhaps none of those 3 are currently at the given area you've chosen. So, with a simple rod and a moth bait, you're options are kinda limited.

The quest should be completed and you should collect the fishing rod reward. Try to get at least 6 and then return to the Lighthouse Keeper at day to give him. Finding moths in Graveyard Keeper Find flowers to pick at night (they are all over the place) and there is a chance you will find a moth. Each question mark is a particular fish, with it's own preferences, determined by an array of variables rod type, bait, and time of day are the most notable. Find ‘Inspects’ and press the A button to unlock it. Upon approaching and activating any of the five available fishing areas, you'll notice three sub-sections, often filled with up to three question marks. Just leaving this here for your perusing, in case you haven't read through it linky

Graveyard keeper moths